Idle hands…don’t belong to kinesthetic learners?

This column is getting a bit old, but since the topic came up a social event (weekly happy hour) recently, I thought I’d post it.

The issue raised by my peers was that of knitting in class. Knitting, as many of you will realize, has made comeback in recent years and more young people than ever are making scarves–and the more ambitious are on to hats, bags, legwarmers, and socks. But is knitting in a public setting–one where you’re assumed to be paying attention and even taking notes–blatantly rude? Let’s find out….

Dear Miss Manners: At a condo association meeting consisting of about 60 people, there was a head table with six people, facing about six rows of tables, about five feet away. In the front row were two ladies — not sitting next to each other — doing their needlework.
Is it proper to do needlework while at an event such as this? I noticed that the speakers were distracted (and so was I) by their movements. Between reading the directions and rearranging their work, one couldn’t help but turn their way to see what was going on. I say it is rude.

Gentle Reader: But what if they don’t have hand-held devices that enable them to check their e-mail, text message and play games while the committee is droning on?
Not that Miss Manners condones failing to pay attention at meetings, or rather, failing to look as if one is paying attention. She merely wants to make the point that there are worse distractions available. Needlework at least has precedent behind it. For centuries, ladies sat quietly doing needlework while gentlemen conversed around them, and didn’t miss a thing of what was going on.

I agree that in this day and age there are plenty of things you can do that are more distracting that knit in class….I would be lying if I said I hadn’t participated in facebook messaging, even live chatting, during class–often with other folks in the same class. At least part of the issue seems to be appearances–if you’re facebooking, MAYBE it looks like you’re taking notes (though most professors would probably argue they can tell the difference). If you’re knitting, there’s no disguise, and no sense of needing one.

But I also disagree with Miss Manners’ deference to precedent on this matter. I would contend that the needlework women engaged in while sitting in on gentlemen’s conversation was acceptable because they were not considered part of the conversation, and not distracting because they literally were not seen. Indeed, in that period the guise of being busy with something else may have allowed many a woman to listen in where otherwise she would not have been welcome.

The problem that this person is complaining about is the opposite: people who are expected to be actively engaged, actively engaging themselves in a different activity. I won’t argue that you can’t knit and listen, becuase it would be pointless. You can, and many people do.. But it does convey a certain level of apartness. You can knit and listen, sure, but you can’t, for example, knit and raise your hand, or knit and take notes, or knit and keep your eyes on the speaker. And these women, it seems, were doing needlework that entailed reviewing and following directions–so that surely required the majority of their attention.

So I guess I don’t really know if it’s “rude” or not. Knitting in unorthodox settings doesn’t bother me as much as it does some of my colleagues. But I don’t think Miss Manners’ explanation is particularly helpful–or even relevant, so much have settings changed.


2 responses to “Idle hands…don’t belong to kinesthetic learners?

  1. My mom was at a bar mitzvah once where the rabbi said, “Turn off your cell phones now. If you think you have anywhere more important to be than here, you are wrong.” That always stuck with me, and I repeat it to my students all the time. However, it is amazing how students can text/e-mail and pay attention at the same time. I can ask a question directly to a kid who is texting under his desk (I CAN tell, by the way 😉 ) and he can answer me without missing a beat or looking up from his preoccupation.Also interesting to note: It might be rude to text or answer e-mails while in class, but if there is something that you feel is pressing and requires a response, is it better to sit there, trying to listen but too worried to really be engaged, or is it better just to send that text or e-mail and free your mind to pay attention?It also doesn’t seem that anyone is too concerned with whether or not the knitters are actually listening, but how it affects their own personal listening skills – the speakers and listeners are distracted by the movements, etc. I think the only reason they are distracted by those movements is that they are unfamiliar to them. However, if someone were sitting right next to them, texting, they probably wouldn’t even notice.

  2. I think you’re probably right about the knitting being distracting only because it’s unfamiliar. I am sort of amused, though, at the idea that these ladies brought their needlework to this meeting, thinking they’re going to stitch and listen, stitch and listen, but they’ve got their directions spread out on the table!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s